Review · IAKOTA Blog
Look for the best recovery mattress topper. You’ll come across rankings, ratings out of ten, and «our top picks». Take a look at who wrote them: it’s almost always someone who sells one of the products featured.
I’m in this market. I’m going to explain why you shouldn’t believe me either, and what you can do instead.
I work at IAKOTA and I reply to customers’ messages. So everything I’m about to write also applies to my brand.
You can stop me right there: a competitor who doesn’t feature in any of these rankings has written an essay explaining that the rankings are worthless. It’s so convenient that it should be enough to discredit me, and I have no response that refutes this objection. It is, in fact, true. What I can do is give you a criterion that works against me as well. If he’s honest, he must condemn me the day I fail to meet it.
Three ways to award yourself a medal
The first: the retailer that ranks first in its own comparison. A headline featuring the word ‘independent’, a score out of ten, its own product at the top, and the word ‘advertorial’ in small print – because the law requires it. It costs nothing and appears exactly where the buyer is looking for an impartial review.
The second: a genuine blog featuring a discount code at the bottom of the page, again from the same retailer. The author isn’t lying. He simply no longer has any reason to try out the competitor, and this omission feels like a verdict.
The third one is the one I was in the process of writing: the salesman who sleeps on his product for thirty nights and says he slept well. He isn’t telling anyone anything new. He’s simply confirming what we expected of him.
Why it works
Because the buyer has no means of assessment. To judge a fabric whose effect unfolds whilst you’re asleep, you’re left with your first impression in the morning – which depends on how your week has gone, what you had for dinner, and the fact that you’ve paid a few hundred euros. In this vacuum, whoever speaks the loudest wins.
There are, however, two devices, and I’ll be honest about how widespread they are, because that’s exactly the sort of thing people tend to round up in this line of work. If you wear a watch at night, you already have the first one. Most people don’t wear one: in France, around one in ten people own a smartwatch or a smart bracelet, and only a fraction of them sleep with it on. For everyone else, there’s a twenty-euro device, and I’ll explain precisely what it does and doesn’t prove.
Our study, and the objection that will be raised against us
We had our mattress topper measured at the CREPS – Font-Romeu National High-Altitude Training Centre, a public institution that does not belong to us. An unpublished internal study conducted in 2024 involving 27 trail runners following an intense training session. After forty-eight hours, muscle strength had returned to 98.6 % of its baseline value in those who slept on the mattress topper, compared with 95.6 % in the control group, who slept without any such device. Resting heart rate had decreased by 7.7 % in one group, whilst it had increased by 6.9 % in the other.
We funded it. It was not published in a peer-reviewed journal; the three groups each consisted of around nine people, and the control group knew they were receiving nothing: nobody was given a fake mattress topper.
People will say: your sleepers knew what they were sleeping on, and simply knowing that is enough to help them recover better. I don’t have an answer that refutes this objection, and I’d rather explain why than simply sidestep it.
The laboratory drew up the list of its limitations itself. The first is the absence of a placebo : nobody was given a fake mattress topper, and the control group knew they had nothing. There was, in fact, a third group, who wore shorts incorporating the same technology, and they ended up at 91.6 % of their starting strength, that is to say behind those who had nothing. I could use this to argue that belief alone is not enough. The same laboratory rules this out: within these same limits, it lists the comfort of the garments and a compression bias. The shorts were tight and caused chafing. Clothing that gets in the way at night impairs recovery, and that explains this result far better than a lack of belief.
These shorts remained a prototype. They have never been put on sale, and they won’t be until they’ve been forgotten for a whole night. A recycled fabric that you can feel against your skin has already lost its appeal.
So no, this study does not rule out the placebo effect. That is its main limitation; it is stated in black and white by those who carried it out, and that is precisely why the only measure that matters is your own.
Our athletes, and what I’m not going to show you
Top-level athletes sleep on our mattress toppers: Kilian Jornet, Rémi Bonnet, Thibaut Baronian and Caroline Colombo. I could tell you what they say about them. But it wouldn’t mean a thing: they’re our partners, and you’d be right to be wary of their opinions.
I could also show you their watch profiles. I don’t have them. I’m not going to make up some averages just to lend them to you, and when I do have them – with their permission – they’ll be here, along with the number of nights and the watch model. In the meantime, I’m not asking you to believe them. I’m asking you to do the same as them, with your own watch.
The only criterion that applies to you
If you wear a watch at night, here’s the test. For two weeks, sleep as usual and note down three averages: your resting heart rate at night, your heart rate variability (HRV), the amount of time you spend in deep sleep. Then sleep on the mattress topper, wearing the same watch and following the same routine, and compare the results. You have 30 nights’ trial at home. If nothing happens, send it back.
Let’s be clear about what these figures actually mean. A watch provides only a rough estimate of deep sleep; resting heart rate and HRV are more reliable. Compare yourself with your own previous performance, never with someone else’s.
If you don’t have a watch, there’s always the multimeter, in AC mode, with the probe on the skin: the reading drops the moment the lead is connected. Thirty seconds, twenty euros, a figure that either goes down or doesn’t, and no brand can alter this in its marketing. Let’s be precise here too, because this is where brands cut corners: this measurement proves that the product does the electrical thing it claims to do. It doesn’t prove that you’ll sleep better.
Two more questions to ask any brand – including us. Who funded the study in question, and how many people were involved? The answer can be summed up in a single sentence. And what happens if you return the product? A brand that believes in its product’s effectiveness is happy for people to try it.
What I'd like to read
A review of this product by someone who doesn’t sell it, based on their own data and with complete freedom to publish the fact that it made no difference. We’re going to offer it to people who have no reason to go easy on us. The day one of them concludes that it has no effect, we’ll link to it from this page.
In the meantime, don’t believe anyone in this market – not even me. Trust your own figures. Two weeks’ worth of data speaks louder than all the accolades we bestow upon ourselves.
Regulatory information. Wellness product: this is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment. IAKOTA products do not diagnose, treat or prevent any illness. The study cited was funded by the brand; its limitations are detailed in the text. This article is published on the brand’s website and written by a member of its staff.
